|
|
Post by Hermione Granger on Jan 8, 2007 18:17:52 GMT -5
Let's leave the question, "Is Snape Good or Evil?" to every other topic about this across the Internet; I think we can all agree he's not a very good person, being a vindictive jerk and all. Remember, "The world isn't divided into good people and Death Eaters."
So. I have my own very strong opinion on whether Snape is loyal to the Death Eaters or the Order, which I'll give here and there in the debate. I'd rather start off with the opinions of others on this site so get crackin' and give your theories.
|
|
|
|
Post by Merlin Ambrosius on Jan 8, 2007 20:17:07 GMT -5
I say ol' Snivellus is with the Order. Why? Because I like Snape, I like Dumbledore, and I like them teamed up together to squash Voldemort. And it's how I roll, in every book, film or other sort of media (except simple things that have definate bad guys who they try to keep personalities away from), "Pfft, he's not really evil. If you look at it from a different perspective, he's actually in the right." or "He's totally going to end up with the good guys, mark my words." However, I hate it when the bad guy repents in fiction. In fact, I raged while were studying King Lear because I hated what happened to Edmund in the end. He was so amazingly cool, and then bam he tries to save Lear and Cordelia. Like Tolkien, I became enraged with Shakespeare.
On the other hand, how cool would it be if he fooled Albus all those years? Even so, I prefer him to be an anti-social, crabby and greasy hero. There should be more Severus', Nathan's and Marvin's in the realm of heros. And no, they're not exactly anti-heroes.
|
|
|
|
Post by Professor Remus Lupin on Apr 12, 2007 15:48:17 GMT -5
I think I'd have to disagree due to the fact that Snape is the reason Dumbledore is no longer alive in the books. I think he will remain with the Death Eaters and if he does go back to work for the Order I think that the members of the Order would still believe him to be loyal to the Death Eaters and they probably wouldn't trust him as much as they might have had he not killed Dumbledore. So I believe Snape has been and will remain a Death Eater until he dies.
|
|
